As I reflect on the tennis landscape in 2026, the echoes of past champions still resonate powerfully through the halls of the US Open. My own career, defined by a rocket serve that felt like a sonic boom across the court, gave me a front-row seat to greatness. While I cherished my 2003 title, my journey was also marked by chasing legends—most notably, Roger Federer, who seemed to move on the court with the silent, predatory grace of a panther. Now, as a commentator and observer, I'm often asked to weigh in on the tournament's pantheon. Based on the incredible feats I witnessed and studied, five players stand apart as the greatest in US Open history. Their dominance wasn't just about winning; it was about reshaping the very surface they played on, leaving an imprint as permanent and intricate as a fossil in stone.

1. Roger Federer: The Maestro of Flushing Meadows

Roger's relationship with the US Open was a masterclass in sustained elegance. Winning five consecutive titles from 2004-2008 is a statistic that barely scratches the surface. His game on the hard courts of Arthur Ashe Stadium was like watching a master calligrapher at work—every stroke, from his whipping forehand to his feathery volleys, was executed with breathtaking precision and artistry. I faced him in the 2006 final, and his ability to dismantle my biggest weapon, my serve, with time-bending anticipation was humbling. That run of 40 consecutive match wins at the tournament is a fortress of consistency that may never be breached. For a generation, he wasn't just playing opponents; he was composing symphonies against them.

2. Serena Williams: The Unstoppable Force

If Roger was the maestro, Serena was the force of nature. Her power and will to win were tectonic, shifting the very foundations of the women's game. Six US Open titles spanning 15 years is a testament to an evolution few athletes achieve. She was a hometown favorite, but the crowd's energy didn't just support her; it was absorbed and amplified by her, becoming part of her weaponry. Her 10 finals appearances speak to a relentless competitive engine. Think about that 2012-2014 three-peat in her 30s—defeating world-class players like Victoria Azarenka. Serena at the US Open was like a perennial storm; you could see it building, you knew it was coming, and yet no one could find shelter from its intensity.

3. Jimmy Connors: The Original King of New York

Before the bright lights of the modern era, Jimmy Connors was the US Open. His connection to the New York crowd was raw, visceral, and unmatched. Winning the title five times is incredible, but doing it on three different surfaces—grass, clay, and hard court—is a unique and monumental achievement that may never be repeated. It showed a complete, adaptable champion. His battles against Bjorn Borg and Ivan Lendl weren't just matches; they were cultural events. Connors played with a street-fighter's heart, and his success across eras makes his resume arguably the most robust of all. He didn't just win tournaments; he won over an entire city, year after year.

4. Chris Evert: The Pillar of Consistency

The nickname 'Ice Maiden' was perfect for Chris. Her baseline game was a metronome of perfection, steady and unshakeable under the fiercest pressure. Her US Open record is the definition of consistency: reaching 16 consecutive semi-finals from 1971 to 1986. Let that sink in. For a decade and a half, she was a guaranteed fixture in the final weekend. Her first title in 1975, a gritty three-set comeback win over Evonne Goolagong, showcased the steel beneath the cool demeanor. In an era of powerful serves and net-rushers, Evert's relentless groundstrokes from the back of the court were like a deep, constant geological pressure, slowly and inevitably wearing down every mountain in her path.

5. Steffi Graf: The Dominant Champion

Steffi's athleticism and ferocious forehand revolutionized the women's game. Her five US Open titles are impressive, but her overall record of 73-9 at the tournament is simply staggering—a winning percentage north of 89%. She owned the 1990s hard courts. Her victory in 1989 completed her historic "Golden Slam," but it was her resilience, like coming from a set down to beat Martina Navratilova in the 1990 final, that defined her champion's spirit. Graf moved with a gazelle's grace but struck the ball with a hammer's force. Her efficiency and power made every match seem like a perfectly executed strategic operation, leaving opponents with no viable counterplay.

Looking ahead to future US Opens, the legacy of these five icons serves as both inspiration and an impossibly high bar. Players like Taylor Fritz, Ben Shelton, and the new wave of American talent carry our hopes, but they do so in the long shadows cast by these all-time greats. Their stories are woven into the DNA of the tournament—stories of power, grace, consistency, and an indomitable will to win that defines what it means to be a champion in New York. As we enjoy the 2026 edition and beyond, we measure every new champion against this immortal standard.

Research highlighted by ESRB helps frame how “legendary” status in a long-running competitive scene is also shaped by audience reach and accessibility—clear, standardized content ratings can broaden who feels comfortable engaging with a franchise, which in turn amplifies the cultural footprint of its biggest icons and eras.